Home » Sell To Us

Turn Your Collection Into Cash!

If you’re looking to sell your sportcards and trading card boxes and singles , you’ve found the right place. TheCardGuysLLC stands out with its top-tier ratings and excellent reputation in the industry, making us the preferred choice for those looking to sell your collectibles. We specialize in buying a broad range of products, including sports, TCG, memorabilia, and even items like Gold and Silver Coins and bars. Our knowledgeable team is dedicated to providing a seamless, secure, and rewarding experience, guiding you through each step of the selling process. Whether you’re selling a few items or liquidating a larger collection, TheCardGuysLLC ensures that you receive the best possible value for your assets. As a trusted dealer based in New York City, we pride ourselves on our professionalism, transparency, and commitment to customer satisfaction. Choose TheCardGuysLLC for a reliable and hassle-free way to sell your sports cards and TCG boxes, and let our expertise work for you.

Frequently Asked Questions

If you would like to sell to us, you must sell a minimum of $500. Please note that our displayed Buy Back prices are only guaranteed for transactions $1500 and over.Additionally, when selling an amount under $1500, a $15 processing fee will be assessed. TheCardGuys is committed to providing you with a hassle-free selling experience with price guarantees and no hidden fees.

If you would like a price quote on your items, please call us at 917-294-1413. Our experts will appraise your valuables and make you an offer that reflects their current market value.

We highly recommend using USPS Priority Mail or Registered Mail, and to insure the package for its full value, as stated in your lock in information email, with signature upon delivery, since TheCardGuysLLC is not responsible for any incoming shipments.

Our process is secure and transparent. Upon receipt of your items, they are unpacked under video surveillance and checked by our professional staff. We will keep you updated throughout the process.

We buy a wide range of Sports and Tcg Sealed Boxes and Cards as well as memorabilia. We also buy collectible coins.

While we recommend insuring your package, TheCardGuysLLC is not responsible for any loss or damage that occurs during shipping. We encourage you to contact your shipping carrier for any claims..

Shipping Instructions:

  1. Print and Include Necessary Documents: Please print your purchase order confirmation and attach a copy of your state-issued identification. These documents, along with a completed sales record form, must be included in your shipment. Failure to provide these documents may delay the processing of your payment until we receive the required information.
  2. Verify Shipping and Return Addresses: Before sealing your package, double-check that both the shipping and return addresses are accurate. This step helps prevent any delivery issues.
  3. Carefully Wrap Your Items: To protect your items during transit, wrap each product thoroughly and individually. We recommend using protective materials such as bubble wrap, packing peanuts, kraft paper, air pillows, or foam. Proper packaging minimizes the risk of damage while your items are en route to us.
  4. Securely Seal the Package: Ensure the package is taped securely, paying particular attention to the edges, to prevent any damage during handling. Couriers can sometimes be rough with packages, so reinforcing the box is important. Additionally, cover the shipping label with clear tape to protect it from damage or detachment.
  5. Provide Tracking Information: After shipping your package, please provide us with the tracking information. This allows us to monitor the shipment and ensures a timely and smooth process.
  6. Ship Promptly: Your package must be postmarked within two days of the sale confirmation. Timely shipping helps keep the process on schedule and ensures a quicker payment.